College Comparison
Amherst College vs Middlebury College: Which is Better?
Side-by-side comparison of acceptance rates, SAT scores, tuition, earnings, and more, updated with the latest College Scorecard data.
School
Amherst College
Amherst, MA
School
Middlebury College
Middlebury, VT
Head-to-Head Stats
| Metric | Amherst | Middlebury |
|---|---|---|
| Acceptance Rate | 9.8%wins | 10.4% |
| SAT Range (25th–75th) | 1360–1550 | 1430–1550wins |
| ACT Range (25th–75th) | 31–35 | 33–34wins |
| Tuition (Out-of-State) | $67,280 | $65,280wins |
| Avg Net Price | $18,246wins | $25,934 |
| Median Earnings (10 yr) | $77,644wins | $76,310 |
| Graduation Rate | 93.4%wins | 92.6% |
| Retention Rate | 96.8%wins | 93.6% |
| Student–Faculty Ratio | 7:1wins | 9:1 |
| Total Enrollment | 1,907 | 2,785wins |
Verdict
Based on the data above, Amherst edges out Middlebury on 6 of 10 measurable categories, including key factors like acceptance rate, earnings, and graduation rate. That said, the right choice depends heavily on your major, financial situation, and campus culture fit.
Amherst Strengths
- ✓Acceptance Rate: 9.8%
- ✓Avg Net Price: $18,246
- ✓Median Earnings (10 yr): $77,644
- ✓Graduation Rate: 93.4%
Middlebury Strengths
- ✓SAT Range (25th–75th): 1430–1550
- ✓ACT Range (25th–75th): 33–34
- ✓Tuition (Out-of-State): $65,280
- ✓Total Enrollment: 2,785
Want a deeper comparison?
Our interactive compare tool lets you add more schools, filter by major, and see financial aid breakdowns by income level.